CASE LAW, BAIL MATTERS

NO BAIL/PETITION CAN BE FILED, IN CASE THE SAME WAS EARLIER WITHDRAWN ETC, UNTIL FRESH GROUNDS AVAILABLE.

2013 SCMR 1509

 PLD 2013 Lah 540

PLD 1986 SC 173

22 a Cr.PC

Even for the purpose of the bail, law should not be stretched in favour of the prosecution.

PLD 1972 SC 277

Matter pertaining to nikahnama/family case, not to be resolve in criminal case.

2013 YLR Lah 201

PLD 1984 SC 95

Rejection of pre arrest bail, no ground for refusal of after arrest bail

PLD 1982 SC 227

2013 P.Cr.LJ Lah 487

 Bail u/s 498 Cr.PC

ABSCONSION

MISUSE OF LAW & COURT’S CONCESSION, BAIL REFUSED

PLD 1981 SC 93

2013 YLR Lah 1914

SCOPE OF PRE ARREST, LIMITED, BAIL REFUSED.

1996 SCMR 71

RELIEF CAN BE GRANTED ONLY WHERE MALAFIDE AND ULTERIOR MOTIVE SHOWN AND NO OFFENCE TO HAVE BEEN COMMITTED.

1996 SCMR 74+PLD 2009 SC 427

MERIT OF THE CASE CAN ALSO BE SEEN AT PRE ARREST BAIL.

2013 SD 488

2013 YLR Lah 1698

PLJ 1989 sc 526

Minimum sentence of the offence should be taken into consideration

2013 MLD Lah 140

 497 CR.PC

ACCUSED DECLARED GUILTY IN SECOND INVESTIGATION, NO GROUND FOR REFUSAL.

2013 PCr.LJ Lah 1190

2009 PCr.LJ 1169

  

SUPPLEMENTARY STATEMENT

2013 MLD Lah 1176

1995 SCMR 1350

2011 SCMR 161

2008 SCMR 1556

LALKARA, MATTER OF FURTHER INQUIRY

2013 PSC (SC AJK) 189

  

ALIBI

NO PROHIBITION AT BAIL STAGE

2013 PCr.LJ Pesh 1318

ONCE THE ACCUSED IS DECLARED INNOCENT IN INVESTIGATION AND IS PLACED IN COLUM NO 2, HE IS NO MORE ACCUSE AND CANNOT BE TREATED SO UNLESS AND UNTIL AFTER SUBMISSION OF CHALLAN IN COURT AND CALLED BY THE COURT FOR TRIAL.

2013 PCr.LJ Pesh 1318

2007 YLR 2209

2008 SCMR 122

2011 SCMR 945

ABSCONDENCE

PLD 2012 SC 222

1985 SCMR 382

PLD 1985 SC 182

PLD 2013 SC 222

2013 MLD 170

1991 SCMR 322

1999 SCMR 304+1373

2013 YLR Lah 730

2009 PCr.LJ 1101

2013 PCr.LJ Lah 487

Contra

2008 SCMR 678

PLD 1985 SC 182

2007 PCr.LJ 1332

2013 PCr.LJ Baluchistan 1284

1997 PCr.LJ 866

2007 PCr.LJ 1332

1999 PCr.LJ 616

2009 YLR 2123

2002 PCr.LJ 1054

1978 SCMR 287

2003 MLD 669

1981 SCMR 93

AFFIDAVIT

1991 SCMR 111

STATEMENT OF THE CO ACCUSED

NOT ADMISSIBLE, BAIL GRANTED.

2013 SCMR 669

2013 YLR Sindh 1687

2009 MLD 773

Contra

2013 SCMR 385+2006 SCMR 1292 +2004 SCMR 283

2013 PSC Crl (SC Pak) 30

 COMMENCEMENT OF TRIAL

NO GROUND FOR REFUSAL OF BAIL

2012 PCr.LJ 746

PLD 1989 SC 585

2013 MLD lah 1214+1176

2011 SCMR 161

2013 SCMR 49

2013 MLD Lah 145

2013 YLR Lah 681+725

Contra

2009 MLD Lah 120

CONSISTENCY

2013 YLR Pesh 42+sindh 44

CONTRA

NLR 2012 Crl. SC 11

2002 SCMR 1380

  

ACCUSED NAMED IN THE FIR BUT WITH GENERALIZED ROLE

BAIL GRANTED

2012 SCMR 1137

2012 YLR Lah 550+1309

1999 SCMR 1320

COMMON INTENTION

QUESTION OF COMMON INTENTION TO BE RESOLVED BY THE TRIAL COURT/MATTER OF FURTHER INQUIRY, BAIL GRANTED

1996 SCMR 1125

2013 PSC CRL (SC AJK) 125

2013 YLR Lah 154

IN CASES OF FURTHER INQUERY.

BAIL SHOULD BE GRANTED IF THE CASE IS OF FURTHER INQUIRY

2013 SD 497

2012 SCMR 1137

PLD 1985 SC 182

1985 SCMR 382

PLD 2012 SC 222

CONTRA

SECTION 420 & 471 (498 CR.PC AS WELL)

BAILABLE

2103 PCR.LJ ISLAMABAD 1197

365 A PPC

Contra

EVERY MEMBER OF THE GANG VICARIOUSLY LIABLE FOR THE ACT, BAIL REFUSED

2013 PCr.LJ Sindh 2103

HEINOUSNESS OF ALLEGATION

NO ELEMENT TO CONSIDER AT BAIL

2013 YLR Lah 1825

2013 MLD lah 1176

COUNTER VERSION

2013 YLR Sindh 1701

IDENTIFICATION PARADE

DELAYED, BAIL GRANTED

201 YLR Sindh 1751

IDENTIFICATION OF THE ACCUSED, THROUGH A BELATED IDENTIFICATION PARADE.

2013 YLR Sindh 208

  

WOMEN CASES

WOMEN…ALLEGATION OF JAPHA ONLY

2013 SD 497

PHYSICAL INFIRMITY, NO VALID GROUND FOR BAIL

2013 PCr.LJ Baluchistan 1284

  

489F.PPC

REGISTRATION OF MANY CASES, NO BAR FOR BAIL

2013 MLD Lah 1238

SECURITY CHEQUE

2013 SCMR 51

Security cheque

2013 PSC Crl (SC Pak) 12

2013 SCMR 51

Contra

2013 YLR Sindh 566

2013 PCr.LJ Pesh 400

  

CROSS CASE/AGGRESSOR?

2013 MLD lah 1357

  

ACCUSED DECLARED INNOCENT BY TWO I.Os

BAIL DECLINED BY SC

PLD 1994 SC172

COUNTER VERSION

IF ONE PARTY IS GRANTED BAIL, OTHER TOO IS ENTITLED FOR BAIL.

PLD 2009 SC 58

1996 SCMR 1845

1972 SCMR 682

Above is not a hard and fast rule

2013 PCr.LJ Sindh 1155

  

CASE LAW ON BAIL

OPINION OF THE POLICE

DIVERGENT OPINION OF THE INVESTIGATION OFFICERS, MAKES THE CASE OF FURTHER INQUERY.

DOES NOT MAKES THE CASE ONE OF FURTHER INQUERY

2002 SCMR 442

2010 SCMR 966

NOT BINDING ON THE COURT.

2002 SCMR 442

FURTHER INQUIRY

CONTRARY VIEW OF THE TWO JUDGES OF THE HIGH COURT QUA THE INNOCENCE OF THE ACCUSED, CASE FURTHER INQUIRY

PLD 1995 SC 34

QUESTION OF COMMON INTENTION IS A QUESTION OF FURTHER INQUIRY.

2013 YLR 1481

CASE OF FURTHER INQUIRY, BAIL CAN’T BE REFUSED.

2007 MLD 1279, Lah 926.

PLD 1989 SC 585+ PLD 1995 SC 34

2007YLR Lah 1551

1998 SCMR 1578

2005 MLD 435

2000 PCrLJ1828

2009 SCMR 1210

PLD 1996 SC 241

1996 PCRLJ 1745

2007 PCr.LJ Lah 1292

Contra

2010 SCMR 61

2008 PCr.LJ 852

PLD 1970 SC 335

PLD 1988 SC 621

1985 SCMR 195

1996 PCr.LJ 753  

IN BAIL ABLE OFFENCES, BAIL APPLICATION NOT NECESSARY

1991 MLD 518

2009 PCr.LJ Lah 1430

IN CASE OF CONCURRENT JURISDICTION, LOWER COURT SHOULD BE MOVED FIRST.

1999 PCr.LJ Quetta 74

1991 SCMR 322

1^st proviso of 497 Cr.PC

Lady accused

2009 PCr.LJ Lah 1430

2000 PCr.LJ Pesh 586

1998 MLD Pesh 1350

Suckling baby Mst. Nusrat vs. state 1996 SCMR 973

BAIL CAN’T BE WITHHELD AS PUNISHMENT

PLD 1995 SC 34

2011 SCR 124

PLD 1978 SC AJK 83

1992 SCR 379

1994 SCR 11

2013 MLD Lah 145

PLD 1992 SC 81

IF THE CUSTODY OF THE ACCUSED/PETITIONER IS FOUND ILLEGAL HE SHOULD BE RELEASED.

2008 MLD Kar 452

1992 PCr.LJ 357

1987 PCr.LJ 2423

1997 MLD 2101

AT BAIL STAGE, LAW IS NOT TO BE STRETCHED IN FAVOUR OF THE PROSECUTION:

PLD 1972 SC 277

OFFENCE PUNISHABLE WITH IMPRISONMENT OF THREE YEARS, BAILABLE.

NLR 1999 Cr 1

DIFFERENCE BETWEEN MEDICAL AND OCULAR ACCOUNT

BAIL GRANTED

2013 YLR SINDH 117

MEDICAL GROUNDS

BAIL GRANTED

2008 MLD 1121

2009 SCMR 212

Criteria, described

1997 SCMR 1275

Contra

2000 SCMR 107

2005 SCMR 1904

1995 PCr.LJ 1733

PLD 1995 Kar 518

PLD 1995 SC 58

DIABITIES PETITENT, BAIL GIVEN

2011 SCMR 1708

NO OVERT ACT, COMMITTED BY THE ACCUSED

2013 MLD 170

1996 SCMR 1654

1998 SCMR 454

2013 YLR Lah 216

2013 YLR ah 216

CASE, NO RECOVERY OF INCRIMINATING ARTICLE, BAIL GRANTED

1997 SCMR 1279

1999 PCr.LJ 30

2003 PCr.LJ 142

2002 PCr.LJ 1072

LALKARA, MATER OF FURTHER INQUERY

PLD 1995 SC 34

1999 PCRLJ Lah 959

1993 SCMR1992

1995 SCMR 343

1978 SCMR 77

PLD 1996 SC 658

2013 PSC Cr (SC AJK) 189

2013 PSC (SC AJK) Cr. 189

CROSS CASE

2009 P Cr R RWP 997

2008 YLR Lah 2098

2008 MLD Lah 232

1998 MLD Lah 1215

1999 PCr.LJ Lah 971

Contra

1992 SCMR 501

1980 PCr.LJ 105

1998 MLD Pesh 1132

                                                                     

489F.PPC

Does not attract in ordinary matters

2006 YLR 1852

Can’t be wit held as punishment

2007 MLD Lah 926

2008 YLR Lah 2027

Offence does not fall in prohibitory clause

2008 YLR Lah 762

2006 YLR Lah 1452+2042+3199

2005 PCr.LJ Lah 1773+677

2007 YLR Kar 1495+Lah 1280+1120+1709+2723

2007 MLD Lah 926

2007 CrLJ Lah 778

2007 P.Cr.R 1512

PLJ 2010 SC 1087

Amir Masood vs the state by Mr. Justice Ijaz Ahmed 658/b/11 dated 6/6/11

Matter related to civil litigation

2007 MLD Lah 1234

Signature, didn’t tally with the accused signature

2007 LR Lah 1810+1879

Complainant himself accused of the same allegation.

2007 YLR Lah 1264

Cheque not issued by the accused

2007 YLR Lah 1378

Bank officer not cited as witness

2007 YLR Lah 1277

2009 SCMR 1708

2011 SCMR 1488

AFFIDAVIT

1994 MLD 886

1993 PCr.LJ 1489

1996 MLD 108

Contra

PLD 1990 SC 83

1996 MLD 218

1983 SCMR 15

1996 MLD 1

2004 PCr.LJ Kar 548+lah 550

PLD 1977 Lah 1261

1995 MLD 1254

PLD 1990 SC 83

INJURY ON VITAL PART, BAIL GRANTED

Contra

1999 PCr.LJ Pesh 973

1996 SCMR 1270

420 PPC BAIL ABLE

2007 PCr.LJ Lah 547

IF IN A CASE, SOME OF THE OFFENCES ARE COGNIZABLE AND SOME NON COGNIZABLE AT THE SAME TIME, MAGISTRATE’S PERMISSION NOT MANDATORY.

2007 PCr.LJ Lah 547

34 PPC

Contra

2009 PCr.LJ Lah 1058

1998 MLD 1307

PLD 1997 SC 547

2005 PCr.LJ 1881

1990 SCMR 315

2003 SCMR 1425

PLD 1992 Pesh 123

CONSPIRACY

2007 PCLJ Lah 1274

ACCUSED ARMED WITH WEAPON BUT NO INJURY ATTRIBUTED TO HIM.

2007 MLD Lah 21

PLJ 1999 Cr C Lah 262

1981 SCMR 1115

TWO PENAL STATUTE ATTRACTING, OFFENCE OF LESSER PUNISHMENT WOULD APPLY.

2007 MLD Lah 44

1999 PCr.LJ Lah 63

1990 SCMR 1045+1090

REGISTRATION OF ZINA CASE ON THE INFORMATION OF MUKHBER, UNWARRANTED AND AGAINST THE INJUNCTION OF ISLAM.

2004 PCr.LJ 1451+2007 MLD Lah 134

EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION

PLJ 1996 CR.C 104

1997 MLD 1565

PLJ 1996 CR.C 1462

2004 PCR.LJ LAH 528

INADMISSIBLE IF JOINT

2013 YLR LAH 744

OFFENCES FALLING IN PROHIBITORY CLAUSE OF SECTION 497 CRPC.

PRINCIPLE, BAIL SHOULD NOT BE REFUSED, EXPECT IN EXCEPTIONAL CASE.

2007 MLD Lah 926

PLD 1968 349

2007 YLR Kar 1495

2005 PCr.LJ Lah 1496

Not a universal rule

2013 YLR Islamabad 626

2009 PCr.LJ 1140

2011 PCr.LJ 265

ABSCONDENCE OF THE ACCUSED:

2oo7 YLR Lah 2102

2007 YLR Lah 1891

1989 SCMR 899

2006 YLR Kr 2351

2007 MLD Lah 1082

1996 MLD 1354

PLD 1996 Kar 490

2009 PCRLJ 1011

Absconder of the co accused

2008 MLD Lah 446

Contra

1996 PCr.LJ 719

KLR 1996 Cr.C 248

2007 PCr.LJ Lah 1332

PLD 1985 SC 402

Abscondence of co accused

2008 YLR Lah 1891

AGRESSOR

2013 MLD Lah 392

1996 SCMR 1845

2009 SCMR 58

  

HARDSHIP

2008 MLD Kar 178

COMPLAINANT AND IO SAME,

BAIL SHOULD GENERALLY BE GRANTED.

2009 PCr.LJ Lah 1273

DELAY IN FIR

BENEFIT SHALL BE GIVEN TO THE ACCUSED.

2013 MLD Lah 70

2012 YLR 545

  

STATEMENT OF THE CO ACCUSED

No value

2007 YLR Kar 1598

1996 PLR 950

1997 MLD 1550

PLD 1996 Kar 372

2007 PCr.LJ Kar 263

Contra

2013 PSC Cr (SC Pak) 330+52

2006 SCMR 1292

2004 SCMR 283

2013 SCMR 385

CONFESSION OF THE ACCUSED BEFORE POLICE

1996 PLR 1233

Prosecution

2004 SCMR 283

1996 PLR 1233

  

CONFESSION OF THE CO ACCUSED

1998 MLD Pesh 1307

1997 PCr.LJ 847

1990 SCMR 315

1997 PCr.LJ 110

ABSCONDENC OF THE ACCUSED:

2oo7 YLR Lah 2102

2007 YLR Lah 1891

1989 SCMR 899

2006 YLR Kr 2351

2007 MLD Lah 1082

1996 MLD 1354

PLD 1996 Kar 490

2009 PCRLJ 1011

2008 MLD Lah 446

Contra

1996 PCr.LJ 719

KLR 1996 Cr.C 248

2007 PCr.LJ Lah 1332

PLD 1985 SC 402

  

HARDSHIP

2008 MLD Kar 178

  

VICARIOUS LIABILITY,

VALUE TO BE SEEN BY TRIAL COURT, BAIL GRANTED

2013 YLR Lah 131

2013 YLR Lah 701

2013 YLR Sindh 164

INJURY ON NON VITAL PART

BAIL GRANTED

2013 YLR 154

  

COMPROMISE

BAIL IN NON COMPOUNDABLE OFFENCES, COMPROMISE NOT REFUSED AT BAIL STAGE, BAIL GRANTED

2013 PCr.LJ Sindh 398

1995 PCr.LJ 1606

2002 SCMR 184

1998 SCMR 464

2004 PCr.LJ 923

FOR PRE ARREST BAIL, HIGH COURT CAN’T DIRECTLY BE APPROACHED.

2004 SCMR 1167

PLD 1974 Lah 256

1991 SCMR 322

1995 PCr.LJ 785

1997 PCr.LJ 901

1999 PCr.LJ 74

  

AGE

CONSIDERED AS BAIL GRANTING FACTOR

2002 MLD 1422

1999 YLR 2487

PLJ 1998 Cr c Pesh 770 + Lah 967

1998 MLD 999 + 2057

2006 YLR Kar 1381 + Lah 2487

2005 MLD 147

PLD 2003 Pesh 138

2002 MLD1566 + 1817

1970 SCMR 30

2004 PCr.LJ 326

PLD 2004 Pesh 70

2002 PCr.LJ 657

NLR 2003 Cr 536

  

Abscondence of the accused:

2oo7 YLR Lah 2102

2007 YLR Lah 1891

1989 SCMR 899

2006 YLR Kr 2351

2007 MLD lah 1082

1996 MLD 1354

PLD 1996 Kar 490

2009 PCRLJ 1011

Absconder of the co accused

2008 MLD Lah 446

Contra

1996 PCr.LJ 719

KLR 1996 Cr.C 248

2007 PCr.LJ Lah 1332

PLD 1985 SC 402

Abscondence of co accused

2008 YLR Lah 1891

  

Statement of the co accused

2007 YLR Kar 1598

1996 PLR 950

1997 MLD 1550

PLD 1996 Kar 372

2007 PCr.LJ Kar 263

Prosecution

2004 SCMR 283

Confession of the accused before police

1996 PLR 1233

  

IDENTIFICATION PARADE

NOT HELD

2007 YLR Kar 2223

2008 YLR Lah 803

NLR 1996 SD 482

NLR 1996 Cr 473

1997 SCMR 462

IDENTIFICATION PARADE, IN PS, OF NO VALUE.

2007 YLR Lah 424

IF DUMMIES ARE LESS THAN 9/10, CASE FURTHER INQUIRY

NLR 1996 SD 688

1997 PCr.LJ 150

Contra

2009 P Cr R Lah 796+980

  

MERE PRESENCE OF THE ACCUSED

ON PLACE OF OCCURRENCE.

BAIL ALLOWED

2007 YLR LAH 1315

  

BENEFIT OF DOUBT AT BAIL STAGE SHALL BE GIVEN TO THE ACCUSED EVEN AT BAIL STAGE.

2013 MLD Lah 145+70

2008 SCMR 1448

2003 SCMR 201

2013 YLR Sindh 110

2013 PSC Crl (AJK) 66

1996 PCr.LJ 783

16 SCMR 1792

PLD 1972 81

  

HEINOUSNESS OF OFFENCE

NO GROUND FOR REFUSAL

BAIL WAS GRANTED

2007 YLR Lah 2099+1551

1996 PCr.LJ 1469

2011 SCR 82

JOINT EXTRA JUDICIAL CONFESSION

2007 YLR Lah 2055

  

ACCUSED IMPLICATED U/S 201 AND NOT IN 302PPC

2007 YLR Lah 1405

107 PPC

2007 YLR Lah 392

CRIMINAL HISTORY

2007 YLR Lah 2105

2008 PCr.LJ Lah 1444

109 PPC

IF NO WORD OF ABETMENT PRESENT, BAIL GRANTED

2006 PCr.LJ SC AJK 1067

2006 PCr.LJ Lah 1072

2005 P.Cr.LJ Lah 1063

2008 YLR Lah 715

2009 SCMR 1210

PLD 1989 SC 633

2007 YLR Lah 392

MATTER TO BE PROVED IN TRAIL

2006 PCr.LJ Lah 1784

NO ROLE ASCRIBED TO ACCUSED, EXCEPT ABETMENT

2007 YLR Lah 1340

2011 MLD Lah 688

PLJ 2009 SC 678

 WHENEVER A QUESTION OF PROPRIETY WAS CONFRONTED WITH A QUESTION OF RIGHT, THE LATER MUST PREVAIL.

16 SCMR 1520

85 SCMR 382

PLD 1985 SC 182

PLD 2012 SC 222

2012 SCMR 1137

2016 SCMR 1593

 THEFT OF ELECTRICITY

Bail refused

2016 SCMR 1527

  

SUPPLEMENTARY STATEMENT

2003 SCMR 426

2006 YLR Lah 14

1997 SCMR 971

2002 SCMR 1304

1996 Law notes Lah 997

1997 PCr.LJ 70

2009 KLR Cr C Lah 46

BENEFIT OF DOUBT

PLD 1972 SC 81

PLD 1972 SC 277

PLJ 1999 Cr.C Lah 1615

2003 PCr.LJ 119

  

EMPTIES

EMPTIES SENT TO THE LAB WITH DELAY

PLJ 1999 Cr.C Lah 1615

PLD 1999 Lah 473

NOT SENT, REPORT NOT BELIEVABLE.

PLD 2008 SC 1

  

COMMENCEMENT OF TRIAL

2007 PCr.LJ 1027

PLD 1989 SC 585

PLD 1989 Lah 233

1987 MLD 1608

Contra

1999 PCr.LJ Lah 1001

1998 SCMR 897

REGISTRATION OF OTHER CASES AGAINST ACCUSED

2008 YLR Lah 2105

2009 YLR Lah 464

2007 PCr.LJ Lah 1444

2013 SC 178

  

MATTER PERTAINING TO PRE ARREST.

Abscondence

Contra

NLR 1996 CrLJ 154

  

NO INDEPENDENT EVIDENCE AVAILABLE ON RECORD

1996 SCMR 1130

  

201 PPC, BAIL ABLE

2009 PCr.LJ Lah 120

  

STATUTORY GROUNDS

1999 PCRLJ Lah 966+948

PLD 1995 SC 49

1998 SCMR 897

1997 SCMR 32

2011 YLR Lah 1008

1998 P.Cr.LJ 358

  

PROTECTIVE BAIL

SESSIONS JUDGES NOT COMPETENT

2009 PCr.LJ Lah 1430

CASES IN PEHO

¾ PEHO, BAIL CAN’T BE WITHHELD AS PUNISHMENT.

2008 MLD Lah 417

2007 YLR Lah 1711

NO EVIDENCE OF SALE

2007 MLD Lah 79

2008 YLR Lah 815

2008 PCr.LJ Kar 1

PLD 1972 SC 81

PLD 1996 SC 241

2009 YLR Lah 2354

VIOLATION OF 103 CR.PC

2008 YLR Lah 815

1999 PCr.LJ Lah 924

1998 PCr.LJ 2008

NO EFFORT MADE BY THE IO TO CALL ANY INDEPENDENT WITNESS TO JOIN RECOVERY.

2009 YLR Lah 1557

2009 YLR Kar 301

SEC 4, BAIL ABLE

2007 PCr.LJ Lah 79

  

497(5) Cr.PC

PRINCIPLE DESCRIBED:

2008 MLD Kar 449

2004 SCMR 1160+231

2008 YLR Lah 330

1999 PCr.LJ Lah 1

Prosecution

2007 SCMR 482

No ill will or previous enmity described

PLD 1983 SC 82+PLD 1984 SC 192

Private person can’t file it, only state has the right.

1998 MLD Pesh 1350

  

498 Cr.PC

PETITION CAN DIRECTLY BE FILED IN THE HIGH COURT.

2004 SCMR 1167

Prosecution

2004 SCMR 1373 

OFFENCE DOES NOT FALL IN PROHIBITORY CLAUSE

2008 YLR Lah 2027

Prosecution

2003 SCMR 573

2009 SCMR 174

2010 PCr.LJ Lah 8

PLD 1997 SC 545

PLD 1995 SC 34

2002 SCMR 442

2003 SCMR 573

2008 SCMR 807

OFFENCE NOT FALLING IN PROHIBITORY CLAUSE

2013 PSC CRL (SC AJK) 125

MATRIMONIAL DISPUTE CAN ONLY BE RESOLVED THROUGH FAMILY COURT AND NOT THROUGH CR COURT.

PLD 2008 Lah 66

STATUTORY RIGHT

BAIL CAN’T BE WITHHELD.

1993 SCMR 72/1983 SCMR 72

1992 PCr.LJ 2325

1996 PCr.LJ Kar 783

2009 YLR Isld 664

2007 YLR Lah 1755+1805+1281

PLD 1989 SC 585

2008 YLR Pesh 2074

1999 P.Cr.LJ 1704

1996 P.Cr.LJ 1309+1305

1993 P.Cr.LJ 733

PLD 1986 Kar 224

Contra

2002 P.Cr.LJ Pesh 182

2007 YLR Lah 1313+1481

1990 SCMR 307

  

BAIL IN 9C.CNSA

LADY WITH MINOR KIDS

·      2009 P.Cr.LJ Islamabad 475+kar 702

Every accused is responsible to his own act

·      2009 P.Cr.LJ Lah 53+700

NO PRIVATE WITNESS

·      2007 P.Cr.LJ Kar 139

·      2007 YLR Pesh 1728

·      PLD 2008 Kar 14

·      1988 P.Cr.LJ 1175

·      1986 MLD 1152+2484+2220

·      1986 PCr.LJ 1223

·      2009 PCr.LJ Kar 102

MEAGER QUANTITY

·      2009 YLR Isld 565

·      KLR 2009 Cr C Lah 63

·      2007 P Cr R Lah 1856

·      2006 YLR Lah 579

ACCUSED, IMPLICATED ON THE STATEMENT

 OF CO ACCUSED

·      2007 MLD Kar 263

·      2010 YLR Pesh 306

·      2001 SCMR 14

·      2000 SCMR 667

·      1999 SCMR 1271

RECOVERY, NOT FROM EXCLUSIVE POSSESSION

·      2009 YLR Kar 717

·      2007 PCr.LJ Lah 896

·      2008 PCr.LJ Kar 1447

·      2009 SCMR 954

·      2008 MLD Kar 442

CHARGE OF TRAFFICKING, PUNISHMENT 5 YEARS, DOESN’T FALL IN PROHIBITORY CLAUSE.

2001 YLR 1847+1848+2005 PCr.LJ 1080+2002 PCr.LJ 677

SAMPLES NOT TAKEN FROM ALL PACKETS

·      2007 YLR Kar 1973

·      2009 PCr.LJ Kar 151

NO CRIMINAL HISTORY

·      2008 YLR Lah 693

·      2004 PCr.LJ 1670

·      2005 MLD Lah 1056

·      1998 PCr.LJ 164

SAMPLE SENT AFTER DELAY

·      2007 PCr.LJ Pesh 514

·      2008 PCr.LJ Pesh 361

STATUTORY RIGHT, AS BAIL ABLE OFFENCE

·      2007 PCr.LJ Kar 875

DOESN’T FALL IN PROHIBITORY CLAUSE

·      2000 PCr.LJ 657

·      2005 PCr.LJ Lah 1779

·      2003 PCr.LJ Kar 1236

·      2008 PCr.LJ Lah 1162

·      1998 PCr.LJ 1444

51, NO BAR TO SESSIONS JUDGE FOR BAIL

·      2001 SCMR 14

CONFESSION OF THE ACCUSED BEFORE IO, NOT ADMISSIBLE

·      2006 PCr.LJ 1251